Difference between Servo Motor and variable frequency motor
1. Energy-Saving Principle Comparison
Variable Frequency Motor (VFM):
Utilizes variable frequency speed control technology to adjust motor speed by changing the power supply frequency, achieving demand-based power output. Its energy-saving principle is based on the cubic relationship between load and speed, significantly reducing energy consumption under low-load conditions.
Servo Motor:
Constructed with high-performance rare-earth permanent magnets, it offers excellent electromagnetic conversion efficiency with minimal heat generation. The system dynamically adjusts current output in real-time based on actual force requirements, avoiding energy waste and achieving precise energy savings.
2. Mechanical Characteristics Comparison
Size & Weight:
Servo motors feature a compact design, with a volume and weight only 60%-70% of VFMs at the same power rating, saving installation space.
Maximum Speed:
VFM: Limited by its asynchronous motor structure, max speed typically reaches 1400 RPM.
Servo Motor: Capable of 2000–3000 RPM, offering superior high-speed performance.
3. Performance Comparison
Control Accuracy:
VFM: Lower precision (±0.5% speed fluctuation).
Servo Motor: Extremely high precision (±0.01% speed fluctuation, ±1 pulse positioning accuracy).
Response Time:
VFM: ≥500 ms.
Servo Motor: Ultra-fast response (30 ms).
Torque Characteristics:
VFM: Significant torque drop at low frequencies (<15 Hz), with potential fluctuations under continuous overheating.
Servo Motor: Maintains constant torque across all speeds, supporting full torque at zero speed.
4. Control System Differences
Control Architecture:
VFM: Three-level control (PLC → Inverter → Motor), introducing signal delay.
Servo Motor: Two-level direct drive (PLC → Motor), ensuring more efficient signal transmission.
Control Method:
VFM: Open-loop control (no real-time position feedback).
Servo Motor: Full closed-loop control with high-precision encoder feedback.
5. Application Scenarios
VFM: Suitable for applications with basic speed regulation needs, such as fans, pumps, and conveyor belts, where high dynamic performance is not required.
Servo Motor: Widely used in high-precision and high-response applications.
6. Energy Efficiency Test Results
VFM: Typical energy savings of 10%-20%, temperature rise around 40-60°C.
Servo Motor: Measured energy savings of 35%-80%, with temperature rise controlled below 30°C.
Conclusion
Servo motors demonstrate significant advantages in control precision, response speed, and energy efficiency, making them ideal for high-precision, high-dynamic applications. Meanwhile, VFMs remain widely used in mid-to-low-end speed regulation scenarios due to their cost-effectiveness. Users should select the appropriate motor based on specific application requirements, performance expectations, and budget constraints.
Editor/Contact Person: Lea
lea@powever.com.cn
Mob/Whatsapp/Wechat：+86 15926413664
